Why a Good Marriage Feels Empty (and Why It Isn’t)
Relationships

Your Marriage Feels Like Nothing. That Is the Point.

The man in my clinic told me that nothing was wrong, which in nearly three decades of medicine has never once been the whole truth. I have changed enough about him that he would not recognise himself, and he is partly other patients too, but the complaint was real.

His blood pressure was fine, his sleep adequate, his marriage by every account a good one. What troubled him was his phone. Friends of his stood on mountain roads in countries he had visited only on maps. One discovered a new restaurant every week, with the gravity of an astronomer naming a comet. Others, photographed over coffee in establishments he wouldn’t call good, were congratulated by strangers, and nothing happened to them. Nothing! But on the rare occasions he posted a holiday photograph, he told me he’d come down with a fever. He had seen it happen too often to call it chance. His wife had a theory involving the evil eye, he had one involving his sinuses, and they had agreed not to test either in public.

“We are not doing anything,” he said. “And now the knees are going. Everyone says, see it while you can. We agree. And we do not go.”

A physician faced with an ache that has no organ goes hunting for the mechanism, and I found it in three places, none of them his knees.

The first is adaptation. In 1978, the psychologists Philip Brickman, Dan Coates, and Ronnie Janoff-Bulman compared lottery winners with their ordinary neighbours and found that the winners were no happier and took less pleasure in small daily things. The mind does not keep a ledger of what it owns. It gets used to it, which is a polite way of saying it stops looking. Marriage is a lottery won slowly: in the first year every gesture registers, and by the twentieth the same gestures have become furniture, and nobody writes odes to furniture.

The second is that the mind is a poor bookkeeper of good news. Roy Baumeister and his colleagues titled their 2001 review “Bad Is Stronger Than Good,” and the title is the finding. We remember the quarrel of 2011 and not the ten thousand evenings that passed without incident, and a good marriage is made almost entirely of the second kind.

The third comes from my own trade. In 1981, the British epidemiologist Geoffrey Rose described what became known as the prevention paradox: a measure that brings large benefits to a community offers very little to each person who takes part. Persuade a million people to lower their blood pressure a little and many strokes will not happen, yet no single person can ever be shown the stroke he avoided. Nobody throws a party for the stroke that did not happen. A good marriage is a prevention programme with a population of two. Its entire product is catastrophes that never arrive, and a catastrophe that never arrives cannot be photographed.

Meanwhile, the culture around him has been quietly rewriting the meaning of rest. His parents’ idea of a holiday was a relative’s wedding in another town, with the itinerary set by the relative. Leisure was something you had, like a cough. Somewhere in the last twenty years it became something you prove. The Indian middle class, having spent generations learning to save, discovered that it was meant to be seen spending, and the passport, once a document, became a personality. A holiday is now a deliverable: the photograph is the product, and the trip is merely its factory. His grandmother never asked her marriage to feel like anything. It was an institution, like the post office, and its success lay in the letters arriving. We may be the first generation to demand that one marriage be a pension, a best friend, a thrill, and a content strategy, then be puzzled when it sulks. The people on his screen were not happier than he was. They were better documented, and documentation is the only kind of happiness a feed can carry.

I did not want to leave him with comfort alone, because the opposite danger is real. Safety can become an excuse. He and his wife had survived everything except motion, and a marriage can be undefeated and still starve, not of love but of movement, until peace turns into a waiting room with excellent chairs. He had a bucket list and, as he put it, no bucket. Peace is the foundation, not the house, and nobody ever bought a foundation and called it a holiday.

So I wrote him an unusual prescription. That night, name one disaster that did not happen today, aloud, to the person beside you: that she did not raise her voice about the electricity bill, that you did not leave a room mid-sentence and mean it. Then spend the safety it proves. A lunch at an unremarkable restaurant. A short walk, as far as your knees agree to go. Take a photograph of it. Post it if you like, I told him, but keep a thermometer nearby.

He laughed, and then stopped at the door with his hand on the frame, a posture I have learned to wait for, because the real complaint tends to arrive when the patient is leaving. We call it the doorknob question. “She has never once asked me to take her anywhere,” he said. “I always took that to mean she did not want to go.” He considered it for a moment. “Perhaps she was only being kind.”

When I listen to a healthy heart, I hear something every physician treasures and no patient thanks us for: the sound of nothing remarkable, a steady lub-dub with no murmur and no extra beat. In the prescription, I write “no abnormality detected,” the shortest and finest sentence in medicine. I have come to think it is also what love sounds like when you finally hold the stethoscope to it. But a healthy heart was never meant to be admired in silence. It is there so that the body can go somewhere.

Related posts

What Are the Secrets to a Quarrel-Free Marriage? Gain Insights from Kalyani’s 42-Year Happy Relationship

Dr. Brahmanand Nayak

Creating Family Harmony: Tips, Tricks, and Insights for a Harmonious Relationship with In-laws

Dr. Brahmanand Nayak

Satisfying Sex in Your Golden Years: Tips and Tricks for Mid-Life Couples

Dr. Brahmanand Nayak

Leave a Comment


You cannot copy content of this page